Skip to Content

Best Pumpkins for Carving – Tips for Picking the Perfect Pumpkin

With October comes the cooler temperatures, falling of leaves, and of course pumpkin carving time. For the perfect carved Jack O Lantern, be sure to familiarize yourself with this list of the best pumpkins for carving.

When it comes to choosing pumpkins for carving projects, not all pumpkins are equal. As a matter of fact, there are over 100 varieties of pumpkins. Some are the edible type that is perfect for pumpkin desserts, and others are better for decorating purposes or pumpkin carving.

Before you head out to your yearly visit to the pumpkin patch, it’s a good idea to know how a little bit about the different types of pumpkins.

Keep reading to find out why carving pumpkins are different, and what types of pumpkins are available for your Halloween project.

Can you eat any kind of pumpkin? Is it okay to carve pie pumpkins? Get the answers to these questions about pumpkin types and more on The Gardening Cook. 🎃👩‍🌾 Click To Tweet

Stack of carved pumpkins with leaves.

The difference between a carving pumpkin and a pie pumpkin

Have you ever noticed, in the grocery store, that their pumpkins are marked as “pie pumpkins” or “carving pumpkins?” If so, you are luck, since this removes some of the guesswork in your quest for the perfect pumpkin.

What is the difference between the two?

Carving pumpkins have thinner skins. This makes them easier to slice into. They also have less guts on the inside, and the guts are more grainy and far stringier. This makes them easier to clean before carving.

Three carved pumpkin and one small pumpkin with words Carving pumpkins, pie pumpkin - What is the difference?

Pie pumpkins are made for baking and they are usually smaller, and rounder with thicker skins. They also have darker, more orange flesh, that is fine grained. This makes the finished pies more appealing in looks and texture.

Pie pumpkins are sugar pumpkins, which makes them sweeter than carving pumpkins. They belong to the winter squash family and can be prepared in similar ways of cooking.

Are all pumpkins edible?

The short answer to this question is yes – you can eat all types of pumpkins. Not only is the flesh of the pumpkin edible but so are the flowers, leaves, skin, stems and seeds. It is nature’s complete food!

Hands with a spoon and bowl of pumpkin puree and pumpkin seeds.

The longer answer is that while yes, you can eat any type of pumpkin, some do taste better than others when it comes to cooking and baking!

All varieties  taste like pumpkin but some have a strong flavor and others are more subtle and sweeter.

Can you carve any type of pumpkin?

Once again, the simple answer is yes. If it’s a pumpkin (or gourd) it can be carved.

However with pumpkin carving you will probably want to select a pumpkin that is made for carving. (affiliate link) This means it will be one with thin flesh  and stringier guts which will be easier for you and your kids to carve and clean.

All pumpkins will start to rot and break down once carved. Look for those with deeper colors and thick skins to get ones that will last longer.

Some of the products shown in the ads below are affiliate links. I earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you if you purchase through an affiliate link. 

Types of pumpkins for carving

Now that we know about carving and pie pumpkins, let’s learn about some pumpkins that are the perfect choice for carving. (You can print this list out in the project card at the bottom of the post.)

List of pumpkins for carving with images.

Should you carve small sized pumpkins?

Most people head for medium to large sized pumpkins and generally avoid the smaller ones.  Their small size makes it easier to slip with a knife when they are carved.

However, they are easier for the kids to handle and if you stick to painted designs instead of carved ones. you can end up with very cute pumpkins and happy kids.

List of medium sized pumpkins for carving

If you plan on carving a simple Jack O Lantern design, you will likely enjoy carving a medium sized pumpkin. Their round shape and pretty color makes them ideal for this project.

Medium sized pumpkin on a white background.

Some popular medium sized pumpkin varieties are:

  • Autumn Gold Pumpkin – Easy to handle size of 7 – 10 pounds with a pretty orange – gold color and very easy to carve. 
  • The Hobbit Pumpkin – Weighs about 10-12 pounds and is very popular in the Western states
  • Jack O Lantern Pumpkin – This smaller heirloom variety was bred specifically for carving into Jack-O-Lanterns. The skin is a deep orange color and is ribbed. This type weighs between 7-10 pounds and stands about 10 inches tall.
  • Magic Lantern Pumpkin – Is slightly taller than wide, medium orange and weighs 16 to 24 pounds – just the right size for Jack!
  • Sunlight Pumpkins – This guy is a bit smaller at 5- 8 pounds. The color of the skin is bright yellow instead of the traditional orange. 

Larger sized carving pumpkin varieties

Perhaps you are looking for a pumpkin that will be the background for a more elaborate pumpkin carving. One of the larger sizes will definitely be a better fit. These weigh about 15- 25 pounds.

Large pumpkin on a white background

Some larger sized pumpkins to look for are:

  • Gold Rush pumpkins – if you like a larger Jack O Lantern, this guy weighs about 15-35 pounds. They can be a bit harder to carve the time spent will have your carving make a statement.
  • Connecticut Field pumpkin is round and orange. It has smooth, slightly ribbed skin that makes it perfect for carving. These pumpkins weigh 15-25 pounds. They were grown by the Native Americans before colonization and were part of the original Thanksgiving feast.
  • Jaune De Paris Pumpkins – If you have an elaborate and large design in mind, this guy might be the choice for you. This yellow skinned pumpkin can weigh in excess of 100 pounds!


Tall oblong pumpkins for carving

Pumpkins that are tall and oblong tend to be stringier inside. This makes precise cuts more difficult but these pumpkins are also lovely to display and worth the extra effort.

The height of these pumpkins allows you to carve designs that are taller than they are wide.

Tall, upright pumpkin on a white background.

Try one of these varieties:

  • Captain Jack – These dark orange, extra large pumpkins have the classic, tall, barrel shape. Since it typically has a flat bottom, it makes it easy to stand without toppling over.
  • Dickinson Pumpkin – Weighs between 10 – 40 pounds and has a roundish elongated shape and a light color.
  • Howden Biggie – This large Jack-O-Lantern, is much taller than wide with an almost rectangular shape. It is dark orange in color.

Best white pumpkin varieties

The color of these luminous pumpkins gives a spooky look to any Jack O Lantern design. Normally, white pumpkins are easier to carve. Your knife will go right through it.

Also if you are going for an no-carve look, or a painted pumpkin, white pumpkins are easier to paint and look lovely in any display.

White pumpkin for carving on a white background.

Some varieties are:

  • Lumina White Pumpkins – The skin of white pumpkins is less stringy and this makes it easy to carve them. The size is 10-12 pounds. Carve them right before displaying since these pumpkins don’t last well.
  • Moonshine Pumpkins – A wonderful small, white pumpkin that is very uniform, and smooth-skinned. They average 8-12 pounds. The pumpkins have long green handles and are perfect for decorating or carving. 
  • Polar Bear Pumpkins – This extra large pumpkin has bright white skin. The big guy weighs in at 30 – 65 pounds making it perfect for an elaborate design.
  • Valenciano Pumpkins – The snow-white skin of this ribbed pumpkin makes it nice for carving. It grows to about 11 – 15 inches across and 7 inches tall.


Best pumpkins for carving with long handles

In pumpkin carving designs, a pumpkin with a long stem (handle) makes the pumpkin easy to hold onto when you are carving.

If you have an opening from the top to insert your light source, a pumpkin with a long handle makes it easy to keep removing the top to light the pumpkin.

Pumpkin with a long handle on a white background.

Look for these varieties of long handled pumpkins:

  • Wolf pumpkin – This round pumpkin has a very long handle to hold while carving. It weighs 15-25 pounds and has a deep orange color with moderate ribs.
  • Howden Pumpkins – This traditional old time favorite for carving weighs in at 18 -26 pounds. It has an intense bright orange color with defined ribs and strong handles for your Jack O Lanterns. The shape is round and slightly tall
  • Tom Fox Pumpkins – This pumpkin is medium sized, averaging about 12-20 pounds and has a deep orange color. Their handles are fantastic – fat, long and sturdy! 

Don’t forget the gourds

Gourds are from the same family as pumpkins and their shape makes them a fun carving medium. They often have necks that makes them easy to hold when carving.

Their smaller size makes them a bit difficult to work with so they are suitable for more experienced pumpkin carvers.

Bottle gourds on a white background.

Avoid those with warts and go for the smooth skinned type. Some to choose from are:

  • Speckled Swan Gourd – This variety has a long crook neck and flat base which makes it perfect for carving. The large bulb grows to about 8 inches and the sweeping neck can grow to 16 inches long!
  • Bottled Gourds – These gourds have a hard, smooth shell. This hard outer shell lends itself to excellent carving. Bottle gourds can also be turned into drinking vessels. Only edible when immature. Before carving a bottle gourd, you must dry it. This can take up to 6 months.

Can Cinderella Pumpkins be carved?

The unique shape of Cinderella pumpkins makes them ideal for decorating. A common question I get asked is “Can you carve a Cinderella pumpkin?”

Cinderella pumpkins can be eaten and carved! Their design makes carving more difficult, however, since there is not as much flesh to carve.

While their plump and flattened shape might make traditional pumpkin designs harder to carve. their coach-like shape makes them idea for turning the pumpkin into a coach.

Blue Cinderella pumpkin on a white background.

For a colored Cinderella variety try Blue Jarrahdale. It weighs about 6-10 pounds and has a pale gray bluish skin.

Tips for picking the perfect pumpkin for carving

Now that you know some varieties that are available, let’s figure out out to pick the perfect carving pumpkin.

PUmpkin patch with all types of pumpkins for carving and eating.

With so many types out there, where do you start? Keep these tips in mind when you head to the pumpkin patch.

  • When you choose, focus on the visual appeal of the pumpkin. Do you like the color and shape? Does it suit the carving design you have in mind? You are half way there!
  • Be sure the pumpkin is healthy and free of any decay or bad spots. These will make the pumpkin rot more quickly.
  • Look for a pumpkin with consistent color throughout.
  • Does the pumpkin have a thin skin? This is needed, particularly for elaborate carved designs. You should be able to easily get the knife through the shell. Overly-thick shells can be dangerous!
  • Press on the pumpkin to make sure it is very sturdy. Any give will mean that your pumpkin might rot quickly.
  • Try to get a pumpkin with thinner walls since this will allow the light from the inside to shine through. Tap the pumpkin and listen for a hollow sound. Lifting the pumpkin will tell you about the walls, too. Heavy pumpkins normally have thicker walls.
  • Be sure the pumpkin has a flat base so it will sit well.
  • The last tip – carry the pumpkin home from the base and not the stem. You don’t want this to come off in your hand!

If you have previously thought that pumpkins were only for decorating, or that pumpkin pie comes from a can,  you have likely never tried growing your own pumpkins.

Now that you are armed with this list of pumpkins for carving, it’s time to look for some seeds for next year’s garden! You can have your own pumpkin patch, ready to provide you with all the pumpkins to carve that you will need.

Admin note: this post for the best pumpkins for carving first appeared on the blog in October 0f 2013. I have updated the post to add all new photos, more information about carving pumpkins, and a video for you to enjoy.

Pin this post for choosing the types of pumpkins for carving

Would you like a reminder of this post for choosing the right pumpkin for your carving project? Just pin this image to one of your Halloween boards on Pinterest so that you can easily find it later.

Stack of pumpkins and words The best pumpkins for carving, how to choose the right pumpkin for your Halloween project.

Yield: 1 printable

Printable List of the Best Pumpkins for Carving

Stack of fall pumpkins.

There are over 100 varieties of pumpkins. Some are best for cooking and baking and others are meant for pumpkin carving. Print out this list of carving pumpkins and add it to your gardening journal.

Active Time 5 minutes
Total Time 5 minutes
Difficulty easy
Estimated Cost $1

Materials

  • Card stock or printer paper

Tools

  • Computer printer

Instructions

  1. Load your printer with card stock or printer paper.
  2. Choose portrait layout and if possible "fit to page" in your settings.
  3. Print out and add to your garden journal.
  4. Use it as a shopping list when deciding what type of pumpkin seeds to plant.

Notes

List of pumpkins for carving with images.

Share on Social Media

Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission from the sale, but the price is the same for you. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising."

Skip to Instructions