One of my fondest holiday memories, for both Thanksgiving and Christmas, is my mum’s butterscotch pie. The pie is rich and creamy, sweet and mum use to make batches of them every year. (She had to make extras, or there would be none left after my brother got started on them.)
Celebrate the Holidays with Mum’s Butterscotch Pie
My mother died several weeks ago, and this is the first year that she is unable to make these pies for us for our holiday celebrations. But with her recipe on hand, the tradition is carried on by my sisters and me. We will make them each year for our own holiday celebrations.
This pie has a traditional meringue topping but there are loads of other pie crust ideas that are possible for holiday pies. Check out these awesome pie crust designs.
You can make your own pie crust from a mix or from scratch, but I just used deep dish pie crusts from the frozen aisle and they worked perfectly. You cook the pie crust first and then add the filling.
Once the pie shell has been filled, has cooled and is set well, just add a whipped meringue from the left over egg whites and a bit of sugar. The meringue is best when it is torched. You can do this with a kitchen torch (best results) or simply brown it in the oven under the broiler for color and some extra texture.
The pie is a test of patience. It takes a lot of stirring and patience while you wait for the filling to thicken. This is one pie you cannot rush. I tried that one year and ended up with pudding! If you put the filling in the crust too soon, you will have a soupy pudding…cook and stir it long enough and the filling holds well in a cross between a mousse and a cheesecake. But other than the stirring needed, the pie is pretty easy to make. Believe me, once you have made it once, you will want it again and again, in spite of the time it takes to make it.
The pie is full of flavor. It is not overly sweet but still satisfies those with a sweet tooth. The filling is very much like a rich butterscotch pudding and the torched meringue topping adds a light ending to the taste.
So worth the effort, believe me. You will love this pie!
- 1 quart of half and half
- 5 eggs (separated)
- Pinch of Mediterranean sea salt
- 7 tbsp cornstarch
- 1/2 stick of butter
- 1 1/2 tsp pure vanilla extract
- 3/4 of a 1 lb package of light brown sugar (dark brown is fine too. It makes a darker pie) You can vary the brown sugar as to how sweet you want the pie so a bit more or less than 3/4 of a box is fine.
- 3 tbsp of white sugar
- Extra milk if needed
- Separate the eggs and save the whites for the meringue which will go on the top of the pie.
- Cook your pie crust until lightly golden and set aside.
- Whisk the egg yolks. Add a pinch of salt and cornstarch and mix well to combine into a paste.
- Place the half and half in a saucepan over a medium heat and add the butter and brown sugar Cook until the butter melts. Add the egg mixture. Stirring constantly, cook until the mixture is quite thick. You may need a bit more milk or half and half at this stage if it is too thick. It should be quite thick, sort of like a cheesecake.
- Remove from the heat and add the the vanilla extract. Allow it to cool slightly. Place in the cooked pie shell and set aside.
- Whisk the egg whites with the granulated sugar until stiff peaks form. Spread on top of the pie and place in a preheated 350º oven for a few minutes until the meringue gets lightly toasted.
Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are "affiliate links." This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission from the sale, but the price is the same for you. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising."